**1/2 Joe McPhee/Johnny McLellan duo
GRAND MARQUIS
(Boxholder)
This pairing of free-jazz saxophone veteran Joe McPhee and young Boston-area drummer
Johnny McLellan results in some maddeningly elliptical improvisations. McPhee's
tenor mixes a burly, vibrato-heavy tone with graceful phrasing, dynamic
variety, and a perfect balance of power and sensitivity. McLellan has his own
ideas about orchestrating the components of his trap set and rarely approaches
anything straight on. His idiosyncratic phrasing, irregular accents, and skewed
elaborations of ideas and tempos give him a original voice on the drum kit, and
it all makes for an oddly balanced pairing. McPhee's ecstatic, convoluted
lines, alternately moaning and roaring vocal inflections, and big tone often
overwhelm McLellan, who seems content either to defer to his elder and act as
backdrop or to follow independent or only tangentially related ideas of his
own. The drummer's spare snare taps, hi-hat ticks, hollow tom-tom rumbles, and
sudden cymbal splashes follow one after the other in succession, sometimes
corresponding to McPhee's phrases, more often not. The tempos are uniformly
slow, which allows McPhee to concentrate on shading his huge tone and crafted
unified statements while McLellan pays careful attention to dynamics, tone
color, and linear progression. But for much of the disc, the connection between
the two is difficult to perceive. They sound like two strangers intent on their
own tasks rather than two friends engaged in a close exchange of ideas and
feelings.
(Joe McPhee and Johnny McLellan perform this Sunday, March 5, at Green
Street Grill. Call 876-1655.)
|